Joseph works as an editor in one of the magazines dedicated to video games. Here, at RecRoomPick, he’s given the opportunity to enjoy the reverse of the medal – the no less engaging world of offline games.
Ryan knows everything when it comes to gaming, both online and offline. Since his early years he’s been in love with arcades, air hockey, and foosball. Finally, he’s given the opportunity to share his knowledge and opinion on the hobby of his life (and even get paid for it!).
Last updated: March 01, 2022
Rec Room Pick is reader-supported. We may earn a commission through products purchased using links on this page. Learn more about our process here
Not all brands offer the best quality in their air hockey accessories, so they don’t last as long as they should. To help you choose the best air hockey pucks to have at hand, we’ve done all the research for you and reviewed only top accessories to meet your needs.
When picking the six products for our reviews, we made sure to look for a few key features. All the pucks we chose are made of high-quality plastic to ensure they last for more than just a few games. We chose a few sets with paddles since these need to be replaced now and then as well. The sets come in a few different colors, including a glow-in-the-dark set for parties. There are different weights and sizes in our reviews, including a mini set, so you can choose the perfect one for the table and gameplay that you prefer. For reviews on the best air hockey pucks and a handy buying guide to help you choose the right ones, keep reading.
If you need the best heavy-duty air hockey pucks, this Dynamo Air Hockey Pucks Set is a great one to try out. Dynamo is one of the leading brands when it comes to commercial-quality air hockey products, so you know these air hockey pucks will last for a while. They do cost a bit more than other brands but their high quality makes them well worth the extra money.
These air hockey pucks are made of high-density plastic that makes them resistant to chipping and damage. They are 3.25 inches wide and weigh 1.4 ounces, so they are commercial-quality for your business or home. They fit best on 7- or 8-foot tables with a good blower to lift the heavy pucks and float them across the table. There are 2.5-inch pucks available as well for smaller tables if needed.
This set comes with two replacement pucks. They come in three color options, including green, white, or a combination of the two. The green pucks are fast and loud for the classic air hockey gameplay. The white ones are a bit slower and quieter for those who want a more leisurely game. The combo pack gives you the best of both worlds, so everyone is happy.
If you don’t like the loud clacking sound when the pucks hit the paddles and the edges of your air hockey table, there are also rubber-covered puck options available for quieter games.
If you’re looking for new air hockey pucks and paddles for your home table, this is a good set to try out. The Hathaway Pro-Series Air Hockey Striker and Puck Set is made with ABS material, so it is quite durable and resists chips, even when you get a bit boisterous during your games. This means your set will last for quite a while before you need to replace it.
The paddles have an ergonomic design that fits comfortably in your hand, no matter what size it is. Even the kids can hold onto these pieces during a game, so the whole family can play with the same set.
There is green felt for the bottom of the paddles, which helps them slide easily on your air hockey table for smooth movements and quick defense. The felt also protects the tabletop, keeping it scratch-free for a better playing surface.
The pucks are 3-inches across, which fits nicely into standard air hockey goals. They have dimples on both sides to help them float nicely on the table. They are a bit light at only 12 ounces, so they may fly off the table if you hit them hard enough, so you do need to be careful if you have any breakables or spectators nearby.
This air hockey set includes a 180-day warranty. This gives you about six months to try out this set to ensure it gives you the gameplay you’re looking for.
You never know when you’re going to lose your air hockey table pucks. They could fly off the table and disappear or you could misplace them between games. That’s why it’s a good idea to have a few replacement pucks on hand. As the Brybelly One Dozen Air Hockey Pucks name suggests, there are twelve pucks included, so you’ll have plenty of spares around when you need them.
These pucks are made of high-quality plastic, so they are fairly durable. Of course, this doesn’t mean that they are indestructible. If you’re using them frequently or being a bit rough with them, they could get some dents or chips in the edges. Luckily, you have plenty of them, so you can grab a new one whenever needed.
The size of these pucks is on par with other professional air hockey pucks on the market. They are 3.25 inches in diameter, so they fit in the standard goals, plus they have a wide edge to hit with your paddles for the perfect shot. They are also light at 0.9 ounces, though they won’t fly off the table with the slightest hit.
All twelve of the pucks in this set are the standard red color, which makes them easy to see, even when they’re flying over the air hockey table during a game. They also look stylish, with a smooth surface that glides easily over the tabletop.
Though they cost a bit more than some other brands, the Dynamo Fluorescent Air Hockey Puck Set has a lot of great features that make them well worth the cost. This set comes with two high-quality air hockey pucks that are durable enough to handle some heavy-duty use.
These pucks are made of high-density polycarbonate-grade plastic, with a smooth finish that helps them slide easily over the air hockey table’s surface. They are a bit heavy at 1.4 ounces but this keeps them on the table during a fast-paced game. These pieces are also 3.25 inches in diameter, so they fit all types of commercial arcade tables at your favorite arcade or in your own basement.
Another great feature that these pucks have to offer is their coloring. They are bright fluorescent green that is easy to see as it flies across the table, even in low-light areas. They are also glow-in-the-dark air hockey pucks, so you can find them in the dark if necessary, plus they look cool flying across the table.
Though these pucks are well-made and durable, there is always the chance of getting a faulty set. That’s why Dynamo has included a 1-year limited warranty with their pucks. This protects you from any manufacturer defects that cause the pucks to chip or break during use. This way, you still get a great set without having to spend more money on replacement sets for your replacement pucks.
The ONE250 Air Hockey Pushers and Pucks come in a wide variety of colors, so you can match them to your table, your game room décor, or just pick a favorite to play with. There are even dual color options, so you can have different colored paddles for each player or team.
This set comes with four paddles, so you can have a spare, put a paddle in each hand, or play on a team if needed. These paddles are made of high-quality ABS plastic, so they hold up well, even if you’re playing every day. The rounded tops are a comfortable size for adults without being too large for children, so everyone can play.
Green felt pads are included for each paddle, though they are not attached when you purchase them. They fit nicely on the smooth bottom of the paddles and allow you to move quickly and easily to defend your goal and try to score on the other team.
There are also four replacement air hockey pucks included with this set, so you have some spares if you lose one during or between games. The pucks are made of the same materials as the paddles, though they are smaller than some other puck options on the market. This adds a challenge to the game since they are harder to hit, though they are easier to knock off the table. They do fit all standard air hockey tables for added convenience.
Mini air hockey tables need mini air hockey pucks and paddles to play the game properly. The EpicGifts Mini Air Hockey set includes smaller pucks and paddles to fit the mini air hockey tables perfectly, plus they fit little hands comfortably, so the kids can enjoy the smaller game size.
This mini set includes two paddles and four pucks. All of the pieces are made of ABS plastic, so they are strong enough to withstand regular use, even if the grown-ups get into the game.
The paddles have rounded tops that are comfortable to hold. The raised edges protect your fingers while giving you a large surface to hit the puck with. There is green felt on the bottom of these paddles as well, which protects the table surface while gliding smoothly during your game.
The pucks are lightweight, so they float nicely on the surface of the table. There is a downside to this, though, since they can fly off the table if you hit them too hard, so you do need to be careful, especially when you’re playing with the younger members of the family.
Another great feature of these air hockey pucks and pushers is the great low price. This means you don’t have to spend a fortune to get a great set for your mini air hockey table. They also come with a money-back guarantee, so you only need to keep them if you’re 100% satisfied with them.
What do we love it for?
High-quality ABS plastic
Great low price
What were we disappointed with?
Pucks are very light
Felt not attached
Things to Consider
Air hockey is one of the most popular tabletop games there is. It’s found in arcades, bars, and basements all over North America. Of course, you can’t play air hockey without the right pucks and paddles. These pieces are durable but can be damaged if handled improperly or you could lose them if you have a party or a few kids at home. Having some replacement air hockey accessories on hand can keep you playing your favorite game for as long as you like.
Features to consider when choosing air hockey pucks and paddles
When choosing a new set of air hockey pucks, with or without the paddles, there are a few features you may want to consider. These features affect gameplay and usage, so it’s best to read them over carefully before buying any replacements sets.
What’s included in the set
The first thing you should look at when getting a new set is what’s included in it. Some sets include pucks only, while other sets come with paddles as well. Though the pucks wear out faster than the paddles, it is still nice to have some replacements for both of these accessories, just in case something gets damaged or lost.
The puck sets come in varying pack sizes. Some sets, like the Dynamo Air Hockey Pucks Set, come with two pucks, which are fine for replacements. Of course, there are larger packs, like the Brybelly One Dozen Air Hockey Pucks, which includes twelve pucks. The larger pack means you’ll have to buy the replacements less frequently, especially if you have little ones in the house who tend to misplace their toys.
The air hockey puck and paddle sets also come in varying pack sizes. There could be either two or four pucks in these sets, as well as a pair or two of the paddles. Like with the puck-only sets, the more pieces there are, the less often you’ll need to purchase replacements. Having extra paddles also means you can play with either one or two-person teams, which is a great option for parties.
Pucks and paddles diameter
The diameter of the pucks is one of the most important features to consider since the size of the puck affects gameplay, plus they don’t fit properly on every table. There are certain sizes of pucks that are designed for specific table sizes.
Large pucks have a diameter of about 3.25 inches, like the Brybelly One Dozen Air Hockey Pucks. These are designed to be used on the full-size tables, which are about 7 to 8 feet, since they are the right size to fit the goals properly, plus the blower is strong enough to carry them across the table.
Light to medium pucks can range from 1.8 to 2.5 inches in diameter. They fit on the 4-foot mini tables and the 6-foot medium tables, though you do need to check the goal size to be sure the pucks you’re buying will fit. If you try a set and they don’t fit in the goal or the blower can’t keep them floating across the table as they’re supposed to, you may need a smaller puck.
The paddle diameter isn’t as important as the size of the puck but it does need to fit your hand nicely. Ergonomic models are designed to give you a comfortable grip as you’re playing. The edge diameter is also something to look at since the wider it is, the more area you have to hit the puck with, which makes the game a bit easier for inexperienced players.
The weight of the puck is as important as the diameter and must also match the type of table you’re using it for. The larger pucks are best for full-size tables since the blowers are designed to lift the heavier pieces during the game. These pucks, like the Dynamo Air Hockey Pucks Set, can weight up to 1.5 ounces, so smaller tables may not have the blower strength to handle them.
Small to medium pucks can weigh anywhere from 0.31 to 1 ounce, so are perfect for the small and medium-sized tables. Trying to use them on a large table won’t work as well, though, since they are more likely to fly off in the middle of a game, damaging the puck and anything it hits, including other players.
When looking for new pucks for your air hockey table, the material used is something to focus on. The sturdier the material, the more durable the puck will be. All of the pucks in our reviews use high-quality plastic, which helps the puck maintain its shape and prevents bending if you press on the center of it. They also won’t chip easily, unless you’re playing air hockey almost constantly or being extra rough with them.
Try to avoid recycled materials when buying air hockey pucks. Despite the environmental benefits, these types of pucks aren’t as sturdy, so they won’t last nearly as long, which means you’ll be replacing your pucks much more frequently.
The gliding ability is another feature you need to consider when buying new air hockey pucks. The way the puck glides affects gameplay, so you should check how they move before you start playing. The weight of the puck and the strength of the blower are important, as we discussed above. You also need to check the smoothness of the puck itself. If the surface or edges are rough, this will affect how the puck moves across the table. They should be smooth all around to ensure there is nothing to hold them back.
To test this out, try putting the puck on the table and pushing it with your finger. If it moves slower than you expected, pick it up and run your fingers over the surface of the puck. If any part feels rough, sand it until it is smooth and try the finger push test again. When they are gliding smoothly across the table, you’re ready to play.
If the pucks glow in the dark
Pucks come in a wide variety of colors, including white, red, purple, and green. Of course, some of these colors don’t show up very well in low-light situations like bars or parties. For those times when the lights are dim but you still want to play, it’s nice to have some pucks that glow in the dark on hand, like the Dynamo Fluorescent Air Hockey Puck Set.
This particular set of pucks are fluorescent green, so they are bright even when the lights are on. This makes them easy to see as they fly across the table during your games. If they accidentally fly off the table, it’s easier to see them on the floor before they get lost.
Then, when the lights go off, these pucks are still perfectly visible. You can find them in the dark and play with them as well without worrying about losing them or missing them when you’re trying to score a goal. These pucks also look cool as they are hit back and forth across the table, so any spectators will be almost as entertained as those playing the game.
Though not all of the air hockey pucks on the market offer this feature, a satisfaction guarantee is a handy thing to have. This means that if your puck isn’t living up to your standards, you aren’t stuck with it.
If the puck is faulty, you can get it exchanged for a new set, similar to the way a warranty would exchange items. If you just don’t like the air hockey pucks, you still don’t have to keep them. This way, if they get stuck in the goals on your table or they fly off during your games, you can get a set that’s better suited to the table you have. You can also get your money back instead to buy a different set of pucks for your air hockey table, so you never have to stick with pucks that you don’t like playing with.
The lighter the weight of the puck, the faster it will move during you’re games. This means that if you’re buying large tables, the ones that are 1.5 ounces will move slower than the lighter ones. Of course, you don’t want to go too light or the puck will fly off the table as you’re using. Check out the weight recommendations for the table you have and buy the lightest puck you can get for it to have the fast-paced game you’re interested in.
Yes, you can buy the protective felts for the paddles separately if needed. These pieces are durable, so they should last for a while but nothing lasts forever. If you need some replacements before you need to replace the paddles themselves, you can buy a set of felts on their own. These are usually self-adhesive, so you only need to peel off the backing and stick them onto the paddle. You can also buy multiple pads at once to ensure that you have some spares on hand when the pads wear out. This keeps you playing instead of halting your games until new pads are delivered.
When it comes to manufacturing air hockey pucks for commercial use, Dynamo is a great choice. They are one of the leading manufacturers when it comes to commercial air hockey products, so if you’re looking for the best quality, pucks like the Dynamo Air Hockey Pucks Set are great ones to try out. Of course, you don’t need to use them for commercial use, you can use these pucks on your basement air hockey table to ensure that you’re getting the best pucks possible for your home games.
Wrapping It Up
Air hockey is a fun game that the whole family can join in on but you need the right accessories to play the game well. All of the products in our reviews are great options but we do have a few favorites.
Our top choice is the Dynamo Air Hockey Pucks Set, which comes with two 3.5-inch pucks, each weighing 1.4 ounces. These heavy-duty pieces are made of commercial-quality high-density plastic, which resists chipping. They also come in a few different colors.
The Hathaway Pro-Series Air Hockey Striker and Puck Set comes with two 4-inch paddles with a comfortable ergonomic design. It also includes two 3-inch pucks, which have dimpled surfaces for smooth gliding. All the pieces are made of chip-resistant ABS plastic for great durability.
The Brybelly One Dozen Air Hockey Pucks is a pack of twelve 3.25-inch standard red pucks. They are made of durable, high-quality plastic, with wide edges and smooth surfaces. They also have a great low price for a pack of this size.